Axel Gelfert
نویسنده
چکیده
The present paper argues for a more complete integration between recent „genealogical‟ approaches to the problem of knowledge and evolutionary accounts of the development of human cognitive capacities and practices. A structural tension is pointed out between, on the one hand, the fact that the explicandum of genealogical stories is a specifically human trait and, on the other hand, the tacit acknowledgment, shared by all contributors to the debate, that human beings have evolved from non-human beings. Since humans differ from their predecessors in more ways than just the lack of a particular concept or cognitive ability, this casts doubt on the widely shared assumption (the „Constancy Assumption‟) that, when constructing a genealogical narrative for a particular concept (e.g., our contemporary concept of knowledge), it is permissible to hold all other factors (e.g., individual „on-board‟ cognitive capacities) fixed. What is needed instead, I argue, is an ecological perspective that views knowledge as an adaptive response to an evolutionary constellation that allows for a diversity of selective pressures. Several examples of specific conceptual pressures at different stages in human evolution are discussed.
منابع مشابه
Manipulative success and the unreal
In its original form due to Ian Hacking, entity realism postulates a criterion of manipulative success which replaces explanatory virtue as the criterion of justified scientific belief. The article analyses the foundations on which this postulate rests and identifies the conditions on which one can derive a form of entity realism from it. It then develops in detail an extensive class of counter...
متن کاملAbsence of a Magnetic Phase Transition in Heisenberg, Hubbard, and Kondo-lattice (s-f) Films
The possibility of a magnetic phase transition in Heisenberg, Hubbard, and s-f (Kondo-lattice) films is investigated. It is shown that, for any finite temperature (β < ∞) and any finite number of layers (d < ∞), the magnetization within every layer must vanish. Thus, the Mermin-Wagner theorem is extended to a variety of system geometries. We also comment on the microscopic interpretation of the...
متن کاملScientific models , simulation , and the experimenter ’ s regress
According to the „experimenter‟s regress‟, disputes about the validity of experimental results cannot be closed by objective facts because no conclusive criteria other than the outcome of the experiment itself exist for deciding whether the experimental apparatus was functioning properly or not. Given the frequent characterization of simulations as „computer experiments‟, one might worry that a...
متن کاملMathematical Rigor in Physics: Putting Exact Results in Their Place
The present paper examines the role of exact results in the theory of many-body physics, and specifically the example of the Mermin-Wagner theorem, a rigorous result concerning the absence of phase transitions in low-dimensional systems. While the theorem has been shown to hold for a wide range of many-body models, it is frequently ‘violated’ by results derived from the same models using numeri...
متن کاملThe absence of finite-temperature phase transitions in low-dimensional many-body models: a survey and new results
After a brief discussion of the Bogoliubov inequality and possible generalizations thereof, we present a complete review of results concerning the Mermin-Wagner theorem for various many-body systems, geometries and order parameters. We extend the method to cover magnetic phase transitions in the Periodic Anderson Model as well as certain superconducting pairing mechanisms for Hubbard films. The...
متن کامل